Cross-sell, upsell and bundle: the difference
A cross-sell adds a different product to the order and leaves the shopper's choice alone: running socks with running shoes, a recipe book with a blender. An upsell asks the shopper to change their choice to a bigger, better or longer version: the 100ml serum instead of the 50ml at a lower price per ml, the 3-pack instead of one, a subscription instead of a one-time purchase. A bundle is a set you build before the shopper arrives, such as cleanser, toner and moisturizer as one listing, usually for a little less than the three separately.
| Cross-sell | Upsell | Bundle | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it offers | A different product that goes with the one chosen | A bigger or better version of the same product | A fixed set of products |
| Price | Full price | Higher price, often a lower price per unit | Usually a small discount |
| Where it shows | Below the add to cart button, in the cart, on the thank you page | Where the shopper picks a variant | Its own product listing |
| Setup | Pairs picked by hand or by an app | Variants and Shopify's discount settings | One listing to create and keep in stock per set |
Most small stores start with cross-sells, because they don't ask the shopper to reconsider and they keep your whole margin. An upsell works best when the better option is clearly better value, like a lower price per unit.
Examples of cross-selling
The second product completes something the first one starts: it's the thing a shopper would have needed anyway, shown while they're buying.
- Clothing: jeans with a belt that matches the wash, a winter coat with a scarf and gloves.
- Beauty: a moisturizer with SPF, foundation with a primer, shampoo with the matching conditioner.
- Kitchen: a cast iron pan with seasoning oil, a coffee maker with a descaler, a chef's knife with a honing rod.
The cross-sell ideas for 16 kinds of stores go through pairs for pet, baby, jewelry, food, electronics, wholesale and other stores, with the product tag each pair depends on.
When a bundle is the better tool
A cross-sell needs no discount, keeps working when one product sells out (the row shows something else) and covers the whole catalog without a listing per combination. A bundle is better in four cases:
- Gifts, where someone buying for another person wants a finished set.
- Starter kits, when a product needs accessories to work.
- Products your orders show bought together again and again, where a bundle makes the pair one click.
- Slow stock, where pairing a slow seller with a popular one can move it without a markdown.
Build bundles for the few sets that clearly help shoppers and let recommendations cover the rest. The recommended pairs shoppers add most often are your bundle candidates. Shopify's free Shopify Bundles app creates fixed bundles and multipacks from the Shopify admin. A bundle doesn't always need a discount: a kit at the normal combined price still saves the shopper time.
Running cross-sells and upsells together
On the product page, put the upsell where the shopper picks a variant ("3-pack, lower price per bottle") and the cross-sell below the add to cart button. In the cart, show cross-sells for what's already there. Keep one kind of offer per spot, so nobody answers three questions before they can check out. Upsells to bigger sizes or multipacks often need no app, because variants and Shopify's own discount settings cover them; subscription upsells need a subscription app.
Where cross-sells show on Shopify
Below the add to cart button on the product page, where shoppers decide. In the cart drawer or cart page, where they've decided and are about to pay. On the thank you and order status pages, as a suggestion for next time. Keep them inline on the page: a popup makes every shopper close it, while a row can be ignored by anyone who doesn't want it. The guide to where to show product recommendations covers what to put in each spot and how many products to show.
Do you need an app yet?
Shopify gives you two free options. Most themes have a "Related products" section that Shopify fills automatically, and the free Search & Discovery app lets you pick related and complementary products yourself. For a small catalog that's enough, if your theme shows the section where you want it. The comparison of Search & Discovery with a paid app covers what the free app can't do.
An app adds more placements (the cart, the thank you page), recommendations you don't have to pick by hand, and numbers on what they sell. Some also add discounts, popups or tests. Prices run from free plans to a few hundred dollars a month, and most rise with your order count; the guide to how upsell apps charge shows how much that matters in a busy month.
It's too early if your store has a few unrelated products, because there's no sensible second item to suggest, or if almost nobody visits yet. Then product pages (clear photos, shipping and returns, a description that answers questions) and getting visitors matter more. Recommendations start to help once you have products that go together, enough of them that shoppers don't see everything on the first page, and some steady orders. Start with one row below the add to cart button, check it on a phone, and add the cart after a few weeks.
The mistakes new stores make are recommending products that don't go together to fill the row, installing several apps that each add a popup or a row to the same page, and paying for testing features that need far more traffic than they have. In the first month the numbers will be small and noisy, so check first that the row shows on your live store, then how many shoppers added from it.
First-time buyers and repeat customers
A first-time buyer is checking whether your store is real, whether the price is the full price and whether the product will arrive. Help that first order with small items cheaper than the main product and things they'll need to use it (batteries, a cable, a refill), shown on the page. Anything that looks like pressure, such as a popup, a countdown or an item added without asking, works against them. Leave upgrades and big-ticket suggestions for later.
A returning customer already trusts you and owns something from you, which tells you what goes with it: the refill timed to when the first one runs out, the companion they skipped the first time, a neighboring category (a candle customer may like your diffusers) or new products in the line they buy. To find them, open Customers in your Shopify admin and filter by number of orders. Shopify Email and Klaviyo can both send a message a week or two after delivery with one or two products that go with the order, and a reminder when a consumable is likely running low. Don't email the same product they just skipped in the cart; suggest the next thing.
How to know it works
Track how many shoppers add a recommended product and what those products sell for, then compare your average order value and the share of orders with more than one item for the month before and after. The guide to reading average order value shows where to find both numbers in Shopify, and the guide to tracking upsell revenue explains what an app should count as a sale.
Where Dropr fits
Dropr does the cross-sell side. It picks recommendations from your own catalog when you install it and shows them on product pages, in the cart drawer and cart page, on home and collection pages, on the thank you and order status pages, and in checkout on Shopify Plus. Its "Bought together" block shows the product with items bought in the same orders and adds them in one tap, at full price. It doesn't do variant upgrades, subscriptions, discounts, bundle listings or emails. If you want recommendations only for newcomers, its Settings page has an option, "Only on a shopper's first visit"; by default they show to everyone. Dropr is free up to 1,000 recommendation views a month.
Frequently asked questions
Is "frequently bought together" a cross-sell?
Yes. It shows different products bought in the same orders, not an upgrade of the one on screen. The guide to frequently bought together explains where the pairs come from on a small store.
I only have five products. Can I still cross-sell?
If they go together, yes: show the other pieces of the set. If they don't, add a small accessory or refill for your main product first.
Are thank you page suggestions upsells or cross-sells?
Either, but the shopper has already paid, so on the thank you page an add starts a new order. Only a post-purchase page, which appears between payment and the thank you page, can add to the order just paid for.