I built Dropr, a paid recommendations app, so I have a stake in this question. Everything about Search & Discovery below comes from Shopify's help center, checked on October 26, 2026.
What Search & Discovery does for recommendations
Search & Discovery is Shopify's free app for search, filters and product recommendations. For recommendations it gives you two lists per product.
Related products are generated automatically for every product. Shopify builds them from purchase history (the product needs past sales), from product descriptions (only for stores with an English storefront) or, when neither is available, from related collections. You can't edit the generated list, and Shopify notes that it changes often, so a shopper may see different products on a second visit.
Complementary products are ones you pick by hand. In the Shopify admin, go to Apps, then Search & Discovery, then Product recommendations, and click Add recommendations. You can pick up to 10 complementary and up to 10 related products for a product, and choose whether to show only your picks or your picks plus the generated ones.
Where the recommendations show
Search & Discovery doesn't add placements of its own. Recommendations appear only where your theme has a product recommendations section or a complementary products block, and you have to add those sections to your product page template in the theme editor. On most themes that means the product page only.
Shopify also hides a recommended product unless it is Active, published to the Online Store, priced above $0.00, not a gift card, not Unlisted and not already in the shopper's cart. Complementary products must have stock above 0. If a pair you set up doesn't show, check those rules first.
Where a paid app adds something
A paid app is worth paying for when you want one of three things. Recommendations in the cart drawer, cart page or thank you page, where Search & Discovery has no section. Recommendations that don't depend on you picking pairs for each product as your catalog changes. Or a count of what the recommendations sell, so you know whether to keep them.
Dropr covers those three. It reads your catalog when you install it and fills "You might also like" and "Bought together" on product pages, the cart drawer and cart page, "Popular right now", "Recently viewed", and the thank you and order status pages, plus checkout on Shopify Plus. It shows views, adds to cart and sales per placement. It's free up to 1,000 recommendation views a month, then $19 every 30 days.
When to stay on the free app
Stay on Search & Discovery if your catalog is small enough that you can keep complementary picks current for your top sellers, your theme already shows the sections, and you don't need numbers yet. A store with 20 products can set pairs for all of them in an afternoon.
Running both
You can keep Search & Discovery for search and filters and use a paid app for recommendations. Remove your theme's product recommendations section, or the paid app's block, from the product page so shoppers don't see two rows of suggestions.
Frequently asked questions
Why don't my Search & Discovery recommendations show?
Usually because the theme has no recommendations section on the product template, or because the recommended products fail one of Shopify's display rules (sold out, unpublished, Unlisted, $0 or already in the cart). The recommendations not showing checklist walks through each check.
Does Search & Discovery work in the cart drawer?
Not by itself. It supplies the products, and your theme decides where to show them. Most themes show them on the product page.