How a threshold raises order value, and when it backfires
A shopper with $42 in the cart and free shipping from $50 has a reason to add an $8 to $15 item instead of paying for shipping. That is the gain. The cost is shipping you now pay on every order above the threshold, including orders that were already that size before you set it. The right threshold makes the first effect bigger than the second.
Pick the threshold from your own orders
In your Shopify admin, go to Orders, export the last 90 days, and sort by order subtotal. Look at where most orders sit. If most are between $35 and $45, a threshold around $50 is within one item for many of them. If you set it at $40, most of those orders now ship free without anyone adding anything. If you set it at $90, few shoppers will try to reach it.
Then check what you have at the gap: products priced around the difference between a typical order and the threshold. Without them, shoppers have nothing sensible to add.
Check the margin before you switch it on
Example, with assumed numbers: shipping costs you $7 an order and your margin on products is 50%. An order that grows from $42 to $52 earns $5 more margin but costs $7 in shipping you didn't pay before, so it loses $2. An order that grows from $42 to $62 earns $10 more margin and gains $3. Orders already above $50 cost you the full $7 each. So a threshold only pays when the added items carry enough margin, which is why it works better for stores with good margins and light products.
If your margins are thin, you can limit free shipping to some products or regions with shipping profiles, or keep a paid option with a lower rate above the threshold.
Set it up in Shopify
- In your Shopify admin, go to Settings, then Shipping and delivery.
- Open the shipping profile and the zone you want, and add a rate (or edit one).
- Set the price to free and add a condition based on order price, with your threshold as the minimum.
- Save, then place a test order just under and just over the threshold to check both rates show.
Tell shoppers about it in the cart. Many themes can show a "you're $X away from free shipping" message, and several apps add a progress bar.
Show what to add
A threshold tells shoppers to add something; it doesn't tell them what. Recommendations in the cart drawer give them an obvious, relevant choice next to the message. Pick add-ons that go with what's already in the cart, priced around the usual gap. The cart drawer guide covers the setup.
Dropr's cart recommendations come from your own catalog and leave out what's already in the cart. It doesn't show a free shipping message, so that comes from your theme or a shipping bar app. If you only want cart recommendations once the cart reaches a certain amount, Dropr's settings have an optional minimum cart total.
How to tell if it worked
After 30 days, compare average order value, the number of orders and your shipping cost as a share of sales with the 30 days before. A higher AOV with flat orders and shipping cost under control is a win. If orders dropped or shipping cost jumped, move the threshold.